Why did you use a thrust bearing and a ball bearing in your vise instead of a tapered roller bearing? Does a thrust bearing really give that maxial torque under high force that its worth the added manufacturing cost of
Does a thrust bearing roll more smoothly under high loads of axial torque compared to a tapered roller bearing?
so it is worth adding the cost of a second bearing to the manufacturing for added smoothness?
What did you find out when you crunched the numbers and ran your experiments?
Link to Beijing SKF
Just a hunch since I don’t know what exact bearings are in the vise, but by separating the load and having the ball bearing handle the radial load and alignment, and the thrust bearing handle the thrust load, each is likely stronger in its given roll than a single taper roller bearing doing both roles would be.
It’s also possible it’s cheaper depending on the exact bearings that were specified. Sometimes you can get bearings for a smoking good deal because they are a super common bearing, so that may be a factor. The common and cheap tapered roller bearings often have a shallow taper angle, so they’re mainly for radial loads, and a little thrust load, not a lot of thrust load and a little radial load (as it would see in the vise). That could mean an expensive low volume tapered roller bearing VS 2 inexpensive high volume thrust and ball bearings.
Again, just speculation on my part based on experience and the shock I’ve gotten in the past for the cost of some bearings. I doubt @Fireball_Jason chose the bearing setup on a whim, so there’s got to be a reason, maybe even the two I suggested.
So you’re still using 2 bearings, but why opposed? They only see load in 1 direction, so you’d be better off using them the same direction to double their thrust load.
Again, I go back to a cheap ball bearing for radial loads and thrust bearing for thrust loads may be the better design choice for a vise. For the end of a ballscrew on a CNC mill or something like that, your opposed tapered roller bearings would be the right choice, since it will see about the same load in 2 directions, and spin quickly.
I’ve looked at one of the fireball drawings & it looks like there are only 2 thrust bearings with the backlash taken out with a spring, there are no radial bearings.
Traditionally, tapered roller bearings are mounted with their tapers opposed. This allows them to be tightened together to preload them, eliminating backlash. It may not be the preferred solution but I would use this tested method for a personal vise to gain radial alignment & eliminate the spring.
For smooth running it may be prudent not to over constrain the far end of the nut.
Just throwing this out as well, I’m familiar with why to used tapered roller bearings opposed, I had to convert my IH CNC mill from using ball bearings with preload spacers (stupid design) to opposed tapered roller bearings to get rid of some backlash issues on the X and Y. Stupid expensive little bearings those were indeed.
But that doesn’t mean tapered roller bearings can ONLY be used opposed. The main advantages of opposed tapered bearings is that it makes it easy to remove backlash from the system and it’ll have the same thrust rating in both directions.
If I wanted to use tapered roller bearings for a vise, unless they were huge or had a steep angle (putting a lot of their strength into the thrust direction) I’d use them the same direction with a different way to control backlash; or be extra cautious about knowing for sure what their thrust load rating is, and that I wouldn’t be exceeding it.
This is part of the fun though, ask 10 guys to design something, and there’s a good chance you’ll have 10 difference designs in your hand at the end of it, you just have to decide what design you’re most comfortable with.
I’ve looked into the capacity of tapered roller bearings & their thrust loads are much lower for a similar size thrust bearing. As you advised, they are not an option for such high forces.
Want more information on Thrust Roller Bearings manufacturer? Feel free to contact us.
Another option is to mount two thrust bearings in a headed sleeve. This allows the bearings to be preloaded onto the leadscrew and this assembly simply slid in from the front. The new headed sleeve assembly can be fixed with a set screw from underneath & easily changed for maintenance.
There is a large hole at the base of the fixed jaw for access to set the original spring assembly after loading the leadscrew & bearings. This hole can now be completely closed off. Preventing grit from entering the inner thrust bearing, leadscrew & nut while also greatly improving the strength of the casting.
Here is a link to a sketch to demonstrate the overall idea with some fillets added to eliminate several stress risers. fireball2-Model.pdf - Google Drive
In the world of industrial machinery and equipment, reliable and high-performance bearings are essential components that ensure smooth and efficient operation. Among the various types of bearings available, spherical roller thrust bearings have gained a reputation for their exceptional capabilities and versatility. In this article, we’ll explore the top five advantages of spherical roller thrust bearings, highlighting why they are a preferred choice for many applications.
When it comes to sourcing high-quality spherical roller thrust bearings, LKPB stands out as a leading bearing company and manufacturer. With a commitment to excellence and innovation, LKPB offers a comprehensive range of these bearings, catering to the diverse needs of various industries.
One of the primary advantages of spherical roller thrust bearings is their exceptional load-carrying capacity. These bearings are designed to withstand substantial axial loads while also accommodating radial loads, making them ideal for applications where combined loading conditions exist. The spherical roller design ensures even load distribution, minimizing stress concentrations and reducing the risk of premature bearing failure.
Spherical roller thrust bearings are renowned for their ability to accommodate misalignment between the shaft and housing. This characteristic is particularly beneficial in applications where shaft deflections or housing deformations may occur due to thermal expansion, improper installation, or other factors. The spherical design of the rollers allows for self-alignment, reducing the risk of excessive wear, vibration, and noise, thereby extending the bearing’s service life.
Many modern applications demand high-speed operation, and spherical roller thrust bearings excel in this regard. Their robust design and optimized internal geometry enable smooth operation at high rotational speeds, minimizing friction and heat generation. This capability makes them well-suited for applications such as turbines, compressors, and high-speed machinery.
Effective lubrication is crucial for the optimal performance and longevity of any bearing. Spherical roller thrust bearings are designed with enhanced lubricant distribution and retention capabilities. The spherical rollers and optimized raceway geometry facilitate efficient lubricant flow, ensuring adequate lubrication across the entire bearing surface. This feature contributes to reduced wear, minimized friction, and extended bearing life.
Spherical roller thrust bearings are versatile components that find applications across various industries, including aerospace, automotive, construction, and power generation. Their ability to handle diverse loading conditions, accommodate misalignment, and operate at high speeds make them suitable for a wide range of applications, such as gearboxes, turbines, conveyors, and heavy machinery.
At LKPB, our commitment to quality and innovation drives us to continuously enhance our spherical roller thrust bearing offerings. Our state-of-the-art manufacturing facilities and stringent quality control measures ensure that our products meet the highest industry standards, delivering exceptional performance and reliability.
Whether you’re an engineer, designer, or maintenance professional, choosing the right bearing for your application is crucial. By understanding the advantages of spherical roller thrust bearings, you can make an informed decision that optimizes your machinery’s performance, reduces downtime, and maximizes your return on investment.
The company is the world’s best TIMKEN Bearings Distributors supplier. We are your one-stop shop for all needs. Our staff are highly-specialized and will help you find the product you need.